Thursday, October 29, 2015

Don't buy the Codina Liek book without reading this post!

Why?  Because you may study it in depth and still fail!  Yup, even though I feel that the Codina Liek book is a good review book to help study for the exam, there are quite a few errors in it.  Some of the answers even contradict her material (which is usually accurate) so be careful!  There were enough that were "off" that they could make a difference in whether you pass or fail!

I also found an error in the Hollier book, but just one!  I emailed Dr. Hollier about it and she very graciously replied (within a few days) and commented on the response.  I really appreciate that kind of response and dedication to accuracy!  BTW, she has a web site where any identified errors are noted with the correction (most where just typos, like, "the rationale given is correct but the correct answer is b").

I also emailed Ms. Codina Liek, and she answered (after several weeks) and said that she was aware of errors and that she would correct them in the next edition!  Wow, the next edition still isn't out (as of October 2015 when I am writing this), so I guess she just expected me to fail the exam while waiting!  She also has a web site, where she talks about how good she is with helping people who have failed previously and it even has updates to JNC 8.  But she refuses to correct any errors in her book.  I consider this (IMHO) irresponsible.  Why would I want to study wrong answers or rationales!  I feel that I paid (by the purchase of the book) for good information and correct answers.  For her to just excuse herself and just say "buy the next edition" really angered me!  It speaks to how unconcerned she is about the accuracy of the information that she is providing. 

So in response to that, I have a list of at least thirty-eight questions, answers, or rationales that are incorrect in her book. Some are minor, some are obvious typos, and some are just plan incorrect!  I will send you a list of them and a little rationale if you would like, I just ask that you promise you are not associated with Ms. Codina Liek (why should I do the research for her new book for her when she is unconcerned about it and she is not compensating me?), and that you leave a comment on this blog after passing on whether or not the information in this blog was helpful for you while studying. (Note: I do not include any questions, just a comment on how it is incorrect or the rationale.  You have to have the book to understand this.  I am trying to be very careful about copyrights, so none of her questions are included.)

I've had several requests for the corrections, but the emails did not include your commitment.  I spent a lot of time on this and am asking for nothing other than this commitment!  Just cut and paste this:  "I will not share the information provided, I will send any one who asks for this information to this blog.  I am not related in any way with Ms Codina Leik and I will not share this information with her or her representatives."  Send this to me in an email to the address below.  I usually respond in 1-3 business days (I do work, so sometimes it takes a little longer). 

I just found that if you do not sign in appropriately I am unable to respond to comments you make below.  So if you would like the list of incorrect questions, just email me at fnptips at gmail dot com.  I usually respond within 24 hours. 

I did not purchase the app available, but I would use it with caution since the questions seem to be the same ones.  A friend of mine bought it; what I reviewed was identical to the questions in the book so I would assume that it has the same errors as well.  

I am open to suggestions as well!  Everybody studies and learns differently so if you have any suggestions or tips, I would be happy to feature a guest post from you after you pass. 

Next: After completing both books


Note: The links in this post are affiliate links and I get a small commission of you use them. 
Copyrighted 2015, N. Sturgill, FNP 

11 comments:

  1. I would love a copy of the corrections to the book. I've just started using it myself. Thank you so much for providing this information. You're blog posts have already been so helpful to me. You've provided some invaluable information on this blog and I can't thank you enough!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lightkeeper2 and others, my email has changed and I no longer get notifications of comments (and blogger won't let me change to my new email) so please re-read the post and email me a the email provided in the post. Thanks!

      Delete
  2. Hey Nelda....I would like a copy of the incorrect answers....I would recommended to get the Leik book and I have the 2014 version and thats what i have been using to study and I take boards Thursday. I want to Thank you for taking out the time to supply the information you did regarding you passing and your study strategy. I really enjoyed your blog!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. To the best of my knowledge, I have the latest version, version 2 of her book, published in 2013 according to Amazon. It is still the latest version available as far as I know. If there is an updated version, i would like to purchase it to review. The errors I found were in this version. From my understanding, there were even MORE errors in the first version.

      Delete
  3. I would like a copy of the incorrect answers to the Leik book. I was recommended her book and i have been reviewing the 2014 version. Im scheduled to take boards onthe 5th of May. Wish Me Luck! I really enjoyed the information you provided, it was really helpful and Thank you so much for taking out the time to do it!!!

    Thanks
    Tiffinee

    ReplyDelete
  4. Lghtkeepr2, please send me an email at the address above, I can not respond from here. Thanks! And good luck!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I would like a copy of the errros please

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Christian, just read and follow the instructions in the post and I will send them to you. Good luck with your studies.

      Delete
  6. I was wondering if I could get a copy of the corrections?

    ReplyDelete
  7. R, just read and follow the directions in the post and I will send them to you.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi Nelda, I just got accepted into the FNP program at TTU Lubbock and I am thrilled by your blog. You really are a light for us new comers. I too would like to have the corrected answers since I am going to follow your plan from the beginning. Thanks for your time and God bless you!

    ReplyDelete